308

Some indices to measure departures from stochastic order

Abstract

We consider indices, θ(F,G)\theta(F,G), to measure the disagreement with the stochastic dominance of the distribution function GG over another one FF, satisfying that there exist random variables X,YX,Y with these respective distribution functions, such that θ(F,G)=P(X>Y)\theta(F,G)=P(X>Y). We analyze the indices corresponding to an independent (the ρ\rho-index), a contamination (the π\pi-index) and a quantile (the γ\gamma-index) frameworks; the cases π(F,G)=0\pi(F,G)=0 and γ(F,G)=0\gamma(F,G)=0 being equivalent to the stochastic dominance of GG over FF. Notably, we show that π(F,G)\pi(F,G) coincides with the minimum possible value of P(X>Y)P(X>Y). The plug-in sample-based versions of these indices lead to the Mann-Whitney, the one-sided Kolmogorov-Smirnov, and the Galton statistics. Asymptotic theories are available which are sufficient for ρ\rho and π\pi. Regrettably, these theories do not cover the bootstrap approximation for Galton's statistic. Then, we provide some additional theory for its resampling behaviour. Moreover, our discussion leads to the consideration of γ\gamma and π\pi as complementary, with γ\gamma describing the level of disagreement with the stochastic dominance while π\pi measures the maximum possible difference in status of a value xRx\in \mathbb{R} under FF or GG. We apply these indices to some real-data sets.

View on arXiv
Comments on this paper