Instrumental variable models are central to the inference of causal effects in many settings. We consider the instrumental variable model with discrete variables where the instrument (Z), exposure (X) and outcome (Y) take Q, K, and M levels respectively. We assume that the instrument is randomized and that there is no direct effect of Z on Y so that Y(x,z) = Y(x). We first provide a simple characterization of the set of joint distributions of the potential outcomes P(Y(x=1), ..., Y(x=K)) compatible with a given observed distribution P(X, Y | Z). We then discuss the variation (in)dependence property of the marginal probability distribution of the potential outcomes P(Y(x=1)), ..., P(Y(x=K)) which has direct implications for partial identification of average causal effect contrasts such as E[Y(x=i) - Y(x=j)]. We also include simulation results on the volume of the observed distributions not compatible with the IV model as K and Q change.
View on arXiv